Site navigation

BT: Don’t Underestimate Scotland’s Digital Infrastructure

Brendan Dick


Scotland's Broadband Infrastructure

Just how well prepared is Scotland for a digital future? As debate and discussion over broadband access in Scotland continues, Brendan Dick, the director of BT Scotland gives his perspective.

Recent headlines suggesting Scotland’s ‘poor’ digital infrastructure could threaten the economy underestimate the country’s digital capabilities and miss the real issue.

The new Queensferry Crossing is a magnificent achievement and is rightly praised – but the roll-out of fibre broadband across the whole of Scotland is an equally successful civil engineering project on a similar scale. It’s on time, on budget and, indeed, has delivered more coverage at higher speeds than originally planned to date, with work ongoing.

So why do we constantly sell ourselves short to the world, and potential inward investors, by claiming our infrastructure isn’t up to the job?

The facts are:

Independent analysis by ThinkBroadband shows that more than 90% of Scottish households and business premises can now order broadband at speeds of 30Mbps and above.
To put this in context, the UK’s independent Broadband Stakeholder Group has previously suggested the average household will require a maximum of 19Mbps by 2023.

So far, only around a third of premises have upgraded to the faster fibre-based speeds. Think Broadband estimates that if everyone in Scotland was to buy the fastest service now available to them over any network, the maximum mean download speed would rise to more than 150Mbps.
The Scottish economy would benefit most from greater exploitation of the internet capacities that are available right now.

Thousands of small and medium sized businesses, with average bandwidth needs, have access to Openreach’s fibre-based network at speeds of up to 80Mbps. (A typical fibre-to-the-cabinet line is around 93% fibre and 7% copper, so to describe it as copper is a bit misleading.)

Meanwhile any business or organisation with significant bandwidth demands can buy dedicated ultrafast services from BT and other services providers with a range of gigabit speeds available. We work with businesses to deliver what they need, where they need it most – not just in city centres.

But the story doesn’t end there. Openreach is now at the start of a new roll-out of next generation ultrafast broadband infrastructure, using both fibre-to-the-premises (FTTP) and its new technology. The latter uses existing fibre and copper, but can provide speeds of up to 330Mbps –and because it builds on the existing network, it can be rolled out very quickly and efficiently, without the need to dig up the roads.

Openreach is currently deploying FTTP in the very rural communities of Skerray and Altnaharra in a trial looking at how such delivery can be made more efficient. And it is working with developers to build FTTP connectivity for free into all new developments of 30 houses or more.

The bottom line is that Scotland can have whatever technology it wants from Shetland to Stranraer, but there is a cost. Detractors, who do not have to contribute to these costs, have said little about how they imagine such services will be paid for.

Scotland is not South Korea, Singapore or even the much-mooted Faroe Islands. The geographic challenges – and associated costs – of laying fibre across Scotland are immense. It’s extremely difficult – and expensive – to bury cable in granite. Most people don’t live in easily-wired apartment blocks – they live in individual homes and scattered settlements in some of the least populated parts of Europe.

The Shetland Islands alone cover a larger geographic area than the Faroes. Singapore’s population of 5m live in an area the size of East Lothian with a population density more than 100 times greater than Scotland’s. Singapore invested £445m of public money to fund its fibre rollout – the pro-rata equivalent would be around £10bn of public money in the UK.

At BT we’re always open to a respectful conversation about infrastructure. Unlike some of our detractors, we’re investing in the digital future for all of Scotland. But as a nation, we need to focus our efforts on making the most of the significant digital capabilities already in place right now, across all sectors of the economy.

Brendan Dick

Director, BT Scotland

Latest News

Editor's Picks Events Featured
%d bloggers like this: